Pat Utomi, Nigeria’s foremost political economist and activist, on Thursday, tested the acerbic tongues of the All Progressives Congress (APC), for claiming that President Bola Tinubu is stifling opposition voices in Nigeria, a dangerous trend, which he said would not augur well for the nation’s democracy.
In a major pushback a day after the acclaimed academic launched the Big Tent Coalition Shadow Government, – the body of opposition politicians put together to synthesise government policies and provide alternative on key issues such as the economy, education, healthcare, and governance, the party, the party dismissed his claims of suppression of the system.
Utomi, had said: “The recent spate of defections to the All Progressives Congress provides further evidence that all is not well with democracy in Nigeria. The imperative is that if a genuine opposition does not courageously identify the performance failures of incumbents, offer options, and influence culture in a counter direction, it will be complicit in subverting the will of the people.”
But Felix Morka, APC spokesman, riposted in reaction: “Utomi is, and has always been, a poster child of freedom of thought, speech, conscience, association, and even freedom of intellectual aggression. Utomi has enjoyed and continues to enjoy his fullest constitutional right to think, say, and act as he chooses.
“He continues to enjoy democratic choice freely, unconstrained and unrestrained. He has gained global recognition as a serial promoter of mega parties, mega coalitions and mega tents, hindered only by the unrealism of his contraptions.
“The suggestion that President Bola Tinubu’s administration is suppressing opposing views is simply preposterous. Utomi’s unilateral declaration of a shadow government, in a presidential democracy, is, in and of itself, an exercise of democratic freedom and free speech in the extreme.
“It is deeply disturbing and desperately dramatic for Utomi to liken Nigeria’s democratic experience to fascist conditions in Adolf Hitler’s Nazi Germany. That approximation is reckless, irresponsible and insensitive and should be beneath a man of Utomi’s standing but has clearly cast reason and rationality aside for sensational and virulent discourse.
“The launch of the shadow government only underscores Nigeria’s vibrant democracy and the Tinubu administration’s commitment to tolerating dissent. Utomi’s partisan disorientation – his failed bid for the Delta State APC gubernatorial ticket in 2019, an unfulfilled stalwart of Labour Party in Peter Obi’s 2023 presidential campaign, and his several dead on arrival third force mega opposition gamble – has clearly taken a huge toll on the erudite Professor’s political judgment.
“That Atiku Abubakar of the Peoples Democratic Party and Peter Obi of LP both campaigned, like President Tinubu, to end the system of fuel subsidy is not propaganda as Utomi alleges in his revisionist quibbles. Rather, it is a statement of fact that both Atiku and Obi campaigned on that policy approach.
“Even as a political economist, Utomi continues to fumble through conversations on the question of an alternative approach to both policies. Simply exploiting and dramatising what are inevitable initial difficulties associated with the policies Nigerians have had to endure for sustainable growth and prosperity is not genius, it smacks of crass political opportunism and desperation.
“No democratic norm obligates a ruling party to build and teach opposition parties how to govern themselves. Just as there is no democratic tenet that prohibits a ruling party from accepting citizens that choose to join its membership. APC bears no responsibility to administer the internal affairs of opposition parties and takes no responsibility for the dysfunction and seeming disintegration of the parties.
“The wave of defections into the APC, while indicative of the rudderless leadership of opposition parties, is a clear endorsement of the visionary and inclusive leadership of President Bola Tinubu, and the massive transformation that is now underway in our country.”