Even before the ink with which the papers were signed is yet to dry, the Senate, on Wednesday, flung out the petition presented to it by Natasha Akpoti-Udughan on the grounds of procedure, ending what could have been a new chapter in the sex-for favour allegations against Godswill Akpabio, Senate President.
Neda Imasuen, Senate Committee Chairman on Ethics, Privileges, and Public Relations, announced this on Wednesday, hours after the Senate got the petition from Akpoti-Uduaghan before the Senate earlier in the day, after obtaining the permission of the Senate President.
Recall that Imasuen, Labour Party (LP) Senator representing Edo South, had tried to pour cold water on the allegation of sexual harassment, where his Kogi Central colleague gave a graphic account on the alleged attempt by Akpabio to bed her, spoke, while appearing on The Morning Show, a breakfast programme on ARISE NEWS.
Pushing back against the allegations of sexual misconduct against Akpabio, Chairman of the National Assembly, he had alluded to the usual penchant for members to mix their official duties with a lot of interpersonal, lighthearted conviviality, saying it might have been misunderstood.
His words: “We have four female senators in this assembly, and I am close to three of them. It is a matter of privilege, and I don’t think it is directed at any individual because of sex.
“We joke a lot in the Senate. If you sit in the Senate for four or five months or even a year, you will understand. We see each other every day. If familiarity is what is being considered as some sort of harassment, then I don’t know. But for me, I don’t think that the conduct of the senate president is such that is against the female.”
Regardless, the Edo Senator, who confirmed that his committee had actually brought forward its sitting on the disciplinary matter now facing the Kogi Senator, assured that Akpoti-Uduaghan would get fair hearing from during the sitting on her matter.
But hours after, he told the members of the committee and petitioners, while commenting on the petition of the female Senator from Kogi: “The petition she presented today, is actually dead on arrival. I say that because it runs contrary to Order 40, subsection 4 that no Senator should present to the Senate a petition signed by him or herself. That petition signed by her will not be entertained by this committee.
“So, ladies and gentlemen, she’s not here and I can understand why she is not here – she’s probably not here on the orders of her lawyers. That being the case, the committee will sit and will deliberate on what we’ve gotten by distinguished Senators that have presented their cases before us and the Sergeant at Arms and based on our Rule Books and all other documents available to us to make a decision here and make a referral to the full Senate.”
Earlier on Wednesday, after the presentation of the petition, commotion had ensued as the matter took a different twist when Senate Chief Whip, Senator Tahir Munguno, contested the validity of the petition based on procedural grounds.
Citing Order 40(4) of the Senate rules, Munguno asserted that any contravention of established procedures is a recipe for “chaos and anarchy.” He argued that the petition was procedurally flawed since Senate rules prohibit a senator from personally signing and submitting their own petition. “Senator Natasha had signed her own petition, rendering it invalid,” Munguno declared.
In response, Akpoti-Uduaghan insisted that her legal case has nothing to do with sexual harassment but instead focused on derogatory and defamatory remarks made about her dressing. She invoked Order 10, which allows any senator to rise and speak at any time, and maintained that her petition should be considered.
Former Senate Leader, Abdullahi Adamu, who stepped in to calm frayed nerves and douse tensions, suggested that since Akpabio had already accepted the petition, it should be referred to the Senate Committee on Ethics, Privileges, and Code of Conduct for review.
However, his suggestion further escalated ruckus, leading to a flurry of points of order and a brief commotion in the chamber.
Senate Leader Opeyemi Bamidele lent credence to those pushing for the rejection of the petition, insisting that no senator can author and sign their own petition. He also pointed out that the matter was already before the courts, as Akpabio’s wife had initiated legal proceedings, making it sub judice and beyond the Senate’s jurisdiction.
“Mr. President, I sympathize with you as a man being accused of sexual harassment,” Bamidele said. “However, we must be guided by the Constitution and our Rule Book, not emotions. You accepted the petition based on emotion, but we must uphold due process.”
In his defense, Akpabio clarified that his decision to accept the petition was not because he was oblivious to the for Senate rules but rather to avoid any public perception that he was deliberately silencing Akpoti-Uduaghan because he was implicated in the matter.
“I took that petition because I didn’t want people who don’t understand our rules to think I was deliberately silencing her,” Akpabio explained.
Despite attempts to call for a closed-door session, Akpabio ruled that plenary should continue. In the end, the Senate upheld the argument of the Senate Leader and rejected the petition, putting the controversial matter to bed in the legislative chamber.