Nothing outside huge disappointment will come out of the current noise by the Peoples Democratic Party (PDP) that they have finally nailed the All Progressives Congress (APC) and Monday Okpebholor at the Edo State Governorship Election Petition Tribunal over the testimonies of witnesses.
Members of the PDP, the former ruling party in the state, have been upbeat since last week, either following the absence of witnesses from the Independent National Electoral Commission (INEC) to call witnesses to testify to the results it claimed to have emanated from the September 21 governorship election, or Monday’s abrupt closure of the governor’s case after calling one witness, who testified that there was overvoting in a part of the local government.
Ifaluyi Isibor, a chieftain of the Peoples Democratic Party (PDP), applauded who applauded the governor’s witness for his honesty, stated that his testimony had further exposed flaws in the election process.
His words: “I must commend the witness for refusing to lie under oath. He could have tried to cover it up, but instead, he told the truth: there was over-voting in Ovia South-West. That is a direct confirmation that the election was flawed.”
Assailing the governor for closing his case prematurely, he said: “With Senator Okpebholo closing his case after just one witness—just like INEC before him—it is clear they have no defence for the heist they committed. If they had any credible argument, they would have brought it forward. Instead, they have chosen silence, which in itself is an admission,” he added.
But Dennis Idahosa, Edo State Deputy Governor, in a quick riposte, dismissed the PDP’s enthusiasm, saying it went into no issue, while insisting that their entire petition was actually a waste of time, adding the results from areas affected by over-voting were already cancelled.
Hear him: “I have refused to comment on the proceeding of the tribunal before now. But today, I feel I have to address some wrong claims being made by the Peoples Democratic Party because the area contesting the result is my constituency.
“In Unit 4, Ward 7, Usen, the results were cancelled due to over-voting, as required by law. Yet, PDP petitioned against these results without knowing they were never included in the form EC8A for the unit results and form EC8B for the ward.”
Arguing the APC witness only confirmed in court that cancelled results were not computed, he added: “Why will the PDP challenge results that do not exist? It shows they do not understand the process. The Electoral Act 2020 (as amended) clearly states that over-voting leads to automatic result cancellation, eliminating the need for further disputes.
“The onus is on PDP to prove their case, but their witnesses have contradicted themselves in court. Our legal team may not even need to call any witness. The PDP is treating the tribunal like a media campaign, rather than focusing on legal facts. The PDP.
“I am here to clarify those facts, to let the world know that those units/wards that the PDP petitioned in Ovia and in other places in the state have been cancelled due to over voting. So it did not reflect in the overall result.”